
Going West: True Crime
Daphne Woolsoncroft and Heath Merryman discuss haunting details of different disappearance and murder cases week by week. New episodes released every Tuesday and Friday.
Latest Episodes
Corpsewood Manor Murders: The Unwelcome Guests // 662
In December of 1982, two men living in a secluded, hand-built brick manor deep in the Georgia woods, who had been the subject of rumors about Satanism, were brutally murdered inside their home. Investigators soon found that, when a group of young visitors arrived at the property one December night, a sinister plan was underway: a plot fueled by greed and rumors of hidden riches that would leave the manor shrouded in darkness for decades. These are the murders of Charles Lee Scudder and Joey Odom…
Sigrid Stevenson: The Phantom of Kendall Hall // 661
In September of 1977, a security officer made a horrifying discovery inside a dark, seemingly deserted theater in New Jersey. There, on the stage, lay the body of a 25-year-old pianist, brutally murdered. But as investigators began piecing together her final hours, they uncovered a series of strange circumstances surrounding the theater, its actors, and the mysterious individual who may have been lurking within its walls. Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for informat…
Rachel Castillo: The Simi Valley Monster // 660
In November of 2022, a 25-year-old woman was spending the day working from home in Simi Valley, California, when she vanished suddenly, leaving behind a terrifying, bloodied scene. As investigators collected witness statements and found her body in the desert, a horrific plot showed itself – the details of which became more and more disturbing as her killer’s confession unraveled. This is the murder Rachel Castillo. Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information ab…
Mary Shotwell Little: A Deadly Secret Admirer? // 659
In October of 1965, a 25-year-old in Atlanta, Georgia, vanished after receiving unsettling phone calls and mysterious bouquets of roses from an unknown admirer. When her car was uncovered, investigators found a series of bizarre clues that only raised more questions. From disturbing evidence to possible sightings hundreds of miles away, the case would take twists and turns that no one could have anticipated. This is the story of Mary Shotwell Little. Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See…
Amanda Blackburn: A Knock in the Dark // 658
In November 2015, a 28-year-old Indiana woman was found unconscious in her home after what originally appeared to be a tragic accident while displaying holiday decorations. But as investigators pieced together local security footage and spoke to neighbors, it was clear that she’d been murdered in a targeted attack. With her husband at the gym during her early-morning slaying, a home invasion seemed the likely conclusion. But the deeper investigators looked, the more unsettling the question becam…
Donna Lass: The 12th Zodiac Victim? // 657
In September of 1970, a 25-year-old nurse finished up a late-night shift at a casino near Lake Tahoe and seemingly vanished without a trace. What followed was a series of mysterious phone calls and letters, which would eventually connect her to one of the most prolific serial killers in modern history. But is he truly behind her vanishing? This is the murder of Donna Lass: The 12th Zodiac Victim? Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection a…
Colleen Ritzer: A Killer in the Classroom // 656
In October of 2013, a 24-year-old math teacher stayed behind after classes at her Massachusetts high school to offer assistance to one of her students. But when she didn’t come home that night, police descended on the school, discovering disturbing surveillance footage and a truly horrifying scene left behind in the woods nearby. This is the murder of Colleen Ritzer. Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for ad…
Mary Stiles: The Baytown Riddler // 655
On Halloween Night, 1985, a Texas girl vanished following what should have been a fun evening of trick or treating. When her body was found nearby, police began an exhaustive search for her killer. Then suddenly, a string of handwritten letters began to come in to the local sheriff’s office, which included riddles that police were challenged to crack if they wanted to unmask a killer… This is the murder of Mary Stiles, and the story of The Baytown Riddler. Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz compan…
Ruth Finley: A Stalker Called 'The Poet' PART 2 // 654
In the continued story of a woman terrorized by a stalker in 1970's Wichita... Dubbed “The Poet,” this unknown person tormented a woman and her husband, and was even linked to a prolific serial killer. After a years-long investigation, detectives began to believe A SHOCKING conclusion… estimating that their suspect was closer to home than they could’ve imagined… This is the story of Ruth Finley. Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection an…
Ruth Finley: A Stalker Called 'The Poet' PART 1 // 653
In the late 1970s, a Kansas woman became the target of a relentless campaign of stalking and terror. It started with anonymous phone calls and letters, but escalated to multiple attacks, the likes of which she feared she wouldn’t survive. For years, her stalker, who had been dubbed “The Poet,” tormented her and her husband, and was even linked to a prolific serial killer. After a years-long investigation, detectives began to believe A SHOCKING conclusion… estimating that their suspect was closer…
Nicole Hutchings: The Fake Halloween Party // 652
On the day after Halloween, 2004, a 21-year-old woman left her Bend, Oregon home to attend a belated Halloween party with friends. But she never came home... So when her family realized she had left all of her belongings behind, a seemingly ordinary night out became a disappearance that would haunt the community for years. Especially once the entire sinister polt was uncovered... This is the murder of Nicole Hutchings. Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information…
Jacob Wetterling: The Masked Man // 651
Description: In October of 1989, an 11-year-old boy rode his bike to pick up a movie rental in rural Minnesota with his younger brother and a friend. But on their way home, the three boys were stopped by a masked man with a gun. Two of them were ordered to run, but one was kept behind, disappearing into the darkness of that autumn night with the stranger. What followed was a tireless quest for justice at the hands of his family that spanned nearly three decades. This is the murder of Jacob Wette…
A Grave-Digging Peeping Tom: The Murder of Tina Tournai // 650
In October of 1995, a 23-year-old Colorado nurse left work and headed out to see someone from her past, hoping to talk over one last dispute before putting it behind her. But when she didn’t return, and her abandoned car was found blocks away, suspicions mounted that she may have been met with foul play. Her loved ones spent years without answers, and her disappearance remained a haunting mystery, until investigators finally uncovered disturbing evidence that led them to her body, buried alongsi…
Arely Proctor: Murdered During an Exorcism // 649
In September of 2021, a California girl apparently began exhibiting strange behavior that required an exorcism from demonic possession - at least as far as her mother was concerned. That night, she was brought to the tiny chapel inside the house where she and her extended family lived in San Jose, which happened to be the church where her grandfather served as pastor. What happened behind those doors over the hours that followed ended with the discovery of the young girl dead on the church altar…
The Devil in Bellaire: Couple Murdered by 'Satan'? // 648
In the fall of 1995, a community was shattered when two members of the same family were found brutally murdered inside their home. But attention quickly turned toward a troubled person with an increasingly disturbing fascination with darkness, violence, and Satan. The investigation quickly flooded with sinister writings, frightening list featuring the names of more local victims, and revelations so bizarre that the case would eventually earn its killer one unforgettable nickname: the Devil in Be…
Ylva Hagner: Into the Bay Fog // 647
In October of 1996, a 42-year-old software executive stayed late at her Bay Area office before seemingly vanishing without a trace. Days later, her car was found abandoned nearby with the keys still inside, but she was nowhere to be found. What followed was a decades-long investigation involving sexual harassment by a university professor, a suspicious, Silicon Valley boyfriend, and a case that would suddenly come back to life more than 25 years after she disappeared. This is the disappearance o…
Diary of a Teen Killer: The Murder of Elizabeth Olten // 646
In October of 2009, a nine-year-old Missouri girl left home to visit a neighborhood friend and never returned. As hundreds of people searched the surrounding woods, investigators began focusing on someone no one could have expected. What they uncovered would reveal a chilling level of premeditation, disturbing online behavior, and a secret diary entry that offered a horrifying glimpse into what had happened in the woods that night. This is the murder of Elizabeth Olten. Hosted by Simplecast, an …
Mary Toups: The Original Witch Queen of New Orleans ft. Emma Roberts
BONUS EPISODE! Welcome to Petticoat Revolution! On our first episode, we meet Mary Toups, the mysterious “Witch Queen of New Orleans” whose life, occult shop, and unexplained death have made her a legend of the city. Daphne, Charlotte, and guest, Emma Roberts, dive into the spooky true story behind Mary, Emma’s own experiences in New Orleans, and what it was like playing the iconic Madison Montgomery on American Horror Story. Emma shares details about season 13 of AHS, tells us about her new pro…
Reagan Simmons-Hancock: The Final Trimester // 645
In October of 2020, a 21-year-old expectant mother spent the morning at home, preparing to welcome her child in a few weeks. But after a trusted acquaintance arrived at her door, an unfathomable crime unfolded…one that stunned investigators and made headlines across the country. This is the murder of Reagan Simmons-Hancock: The Final Trimester. Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Natalie Wood: Hollywood's Mystery at Sea // 644
In November of 1981, a 43-year-old actress vanished from her yacht off the coast of Southern California during what was supposed to be a relaxing holiday weekend away. As investigators pieced together the final hours aboard the boat - a night of mounting tension, conflicting accounts, and unanswered cries in the darkness – questions emerged about what really happened after she disappeared into the water. What began as a shocking Hollywood tragedy involving three major stars would become one of t…
Podcasts

Armed Lutheran Radio
Lloyd Bailey

Blocked and Reported
Katie Herzog and Jesse Singal

Gaston Speaks
Gaston County Public Library

Dakota Spotlight: True Crime & Cold Case Investigations
James Wolner | Investigative Journalist & Creator of Dakota Spotlight

21andsensory Podcast
Emily @21andsensory

Brave Little State
Vermont Public