
Hidden Killers Live! Daily True Crime News & Breakdowns
Listen to your favorite podcasts on RadaRadio. Thousands of podcasts at your fingertips.
Latest Episodes
Can Patrick Clancy's 60 Minutes Interview Be Used in Court?
Live on Hidden Killers, criminal defense attorney Bob Motta and I go through the entire Lindsay Clancy retrial in one sitting: the DA's decision, the prosecution, the defense and every person who gets pulled back in. Patrick Clancy told 60 Minutes that Lindsay described the night their children died as like a dream, and that she never asked him to forgive her. He testified first for the state the last time. Bob explains what happens if what he said on TV doesn't match what he says on the stand. …
Lindsay Clancy's Own Lawsuit Could Be Used Against Her
Live on Hidden Killers, criminal defense attorney Bob Motta and I get into everyone the Lindsay Clancy retrial drags back into court, and one civil filing that could cut against Lindsay herself. Lindsay Clancy's malpractice lawsuit says her providers missed bipolar disorder and that her medications triggered a psychotic break. It also says a voice was telling her to harm her children in the days before they died. Her psychiatrist, Dr. Jennifer Tufts, testified that on their last call, the day be…
Lindsay Clancy's Lawyer Switched His Argument After the Mistrial
Live on Hidden Killers, criminal defense attorney Bob Motta and I take on the defense side of the Lindsay Clancy retrial, starting with an argument legal analysts called a surprise shift. At trial, Kevin Reddington never disputed that Lindsay Clancy killed Cora, Dawson and Callan. His case was that postpartum psychosis left her unable to stop herself. After the mistrial, Reddington asked Judge William Sullivan to rule the state never proved she did it. Sullivan said no. He also rejected a double…
Lindsay Clancy's Prosecutors Said She Wanted a Quick Fix. Their Own Expert Pushed Back.
Live on Hidden Killers, criminal defense attorney Bob Motta and I look at the Lindsay Clancy retrial through the prosecution's eyes, and at testimony from their own expert that could follow them into round two. Prosecutors told the first jury Lindsay Clancy planned the deaths of her three children and knew it was wrong. Three state experts backed them up. But when defense attorney Kevin Reddington read part of the state's opening to Dr. Gregory Saathoff, Saathoff said that description really min…
Lindsay Clancy Wanted a Judge. The DA Says It Needs a Jury.
Lindsay Clancy will face a second jury in the deaths of her children, and live on Hidden Killers, criminal defense attorney Bob Motta and I dig into why. Jury selection in the Lindsay Clancy retrial is set for March 29. The fight over who decides this case matters more than it sounds. Reddington wanted a judge. Prosecutors told Judge William Sullivan the case needs a jury, and her lawyer says that points to first-degree murder, the one charge a judge can't decide alone. First-degree carries life…
JonBenét Ramsey and Alex Murdaugh: Is the Big Evidence Pointing the Wrong Way?
Live with Producer Todd and Lisa, I take on two cases where the most famous evidence is under fire. In JonBenét Ramsey's murder, the unknown DNA that cleared her family is so small outside experts say it could be innocent. In Alex Murdaugh's case, the blood spatter on his shirt that people talked about for years was never confirmed as blood. We start in Boulder with the ransom note, the $118,000, the 911 call, and the pineapple Patsy said she never gave JonBenét. Then where it stands now: the DA…
Will Alex Murdaugh Be Found Guilty Again for Maggie and Paul?
Alex Murdaugh's murder convictions were overturned because a court clerk got into the jury's heads. Now he gets a second trial, in Sumter County, with a jury that's never been near Walterboro. Prosecutors have to make their case again from nothing. Live with Producer Todd and Lisa, I go through what could swing it. SLED found DNA from an unknown man under Maggie's fingernails, and a private lab is testing it over the State's objection. The Supreme Court told the new judge to limit the evidence a…
Alex Murdaugh: Do You Still Believe He Did It After the Spatter Fight?
The blood spatter on Alex Murdaugh's shirt became one of the most repeated details in the case. Now his lawyers say it was never real. SLED's lab tested the shirt and found no human blood, and the defense says the grand jury was told otherwise. Live with Producer Todd and Lisa, I ask the question people are actually wrestling with: what do you still believe? The kennel video from Paul's phone puts Alex there minutes before the shootings, and he lied about it to police. Prosecutors say that, the …
JonBenét Ramsey's Father Made Boulder a Dare. Will They Take It?
Thirty years after JonBenét Ramsey was found in her family's basement, Boulder's DA says nobody has been ruled out, and her father is pushing back hard. John Ramsey told Michael Dougherty exactly what he should do if Boulder still thinks he's guilty. Live with Producer Todd and Lisa, I go through the latest from Boulder. Chief Stephen Redfearn says items tested decades ago are being tested again. The unknown man's DNA from JonBenét's clothes is the department's main focus, while outside experts …
Who Wrote JonBenét Ramsey's Ransom Note on a Pad From Her Own Home?
JonBenét Ramsey was six when her father found her in the family's basement, hours after her mother found a ransom note on the stairs. That note was written in the house, with the family's own paper and pen. Investigators say there was a practice draft in the same pad. Live with Producer Todd and Lisa, I go through every question that still doesn't add up. Why ask for $118,000, almost the exact amount of John Ramsey's bonus? Why would anyone holding that note call 911 within minutes? Where did th…
Sandra Birchmore's Jury Was Split. What Pushed Them to Guilty?
Sandra Birchmore's jury told the judge it was in a deadlock, then convicted Matthew Farwell of killing her and causing the death of her unborn son. Retired FBI agents Jennifer Coffindaffer and Robin Dreeke join me for the full conversation, starting with what pushed those jurors to guilty. We dig into the medical testimony that pulled the trial in two directions and the evidence that won out. Incoming DA Djuna Perkins says her office should have done the job the feds did, and Jen and Robin talk …
Matthew Farwell's Old Cases: Should Every One Be Reopened?
Matthew Farwell was a detective before he was a defendant, and retired FBI agents Jennifer Coffindaffer and Robin Dreeke join me to talk about whether every case he worked should be reopened. A federal jury convicted Farwell of killing Sandra Birchmore and causing the death of her unborn son. Sandra's death was first ruled a suicide after an investigation by state troopers assigned to the Norfolk County DA's office. Prosecutors at trial said the lead investigator went too easy on Farwell. A stat…
Sandra Birchmore's Case Has One Conviction. Is Another Arrest Coming?
Sandra Birchmore's case has one conviction, and retired FBI agents Jennifer Coffindaffer and Robin Dreeke join me to talk about whether another arrest could follow. Matthew Farwell was convicted of killing Sandra and causing the death of her unborn son, and he's the only person charged. Incoming district attorney Djuna Perkins says she'll open a grand jury into the Stoughton police Explorers program. Chief Donna McNamara says the town manager told her to destroy a report on the case, and he says…
Can Sandra Birchmore's New DA Investigate Her Own Office Fairly?
Djuna Perkins takes over the Norfolk County DA's office in January and says she'll find out what went wrong in Sandra Birchmore's case. Retired FBI agents Jennifer Coffindaffer and Robin Dreeke join me to talk about whether a DA can fairly investigate her own office. Perkins says the federal government did a job her office should have done. Matthew Farwell was convicted in federal court of killing Sandra and causing the death of her unborn son, and the county never charged him. The medical exami…
Sandra Birchmore's Jury Nearly Couldn't Convict. What Almost Saved Farwell?
Sandra Birchmore's jury sent a note saying it was in a deadlock, and the next afternoon it convicted Matthew Farwell of killing her and causing the death of her unborn son. Retired FBI Special Agent Jennifer Coffindaffer and Robin Dreeke, the former chief of the FBI's Counterintelligence Behavioral Analysis Program, join me to talk about how close this case came to slipping away. The medical testimony pulled in two directions. The doctor who did Sandra's autopsy has never called her death a homi…
Farwell Is Guilty. Why Is Sandra Still on Trial?!
Matthew Farwell was convicted of killing Sandra Birchmore and her unborn son. That is the verdict. Yet the defense that jurors rejected depended in part on making Sandra’s private struggles central to the story. Tony Brueski and psychotherapist Shavaun Scott ask why a woman’s emotional pain so often becomes the explanation for violence committed against her. Jurors heard the suicide theory, Sandra’s mental-health history and the defense’s interpretation of her pregnancy announcements. They also …
Alex Murdaugh: Coffindaffer Questions WHAT SLED Missed?!
Jennifer Coffindaffer has a question about the Moselle crime scene: how do investigators know they captured everything when the property went back to the Murdaugh family so quickly? Tony Brueski puts that issue alongside the State's new response to a motion attacking the indictments that launched the murder case. The episode revisits the claim that a law partner discovered something inside the feed room after SLED finished its initial work. Coffindaffer also considers a tire track reportedly not…
Farwell’s Jury Was DEADLOCKED—Then Came WHAT?!
Imagine waiting through four weeks of testimony in the Matthew Farwell murder trial, only to hear the jury say it cannot agree. That is where Sandra Birchmore’s family stood before the jury returned with guilty verdicts on November 10. Tony Brueski follows those hours in order: two notes from jurors, Chief Judge Denise Casper’s refusal to end deliberations prematurely, and a courtroom where family members audibly reacted as the verdicts were announced. Farwell was convicted of killing Sandra to …
Farwell’s Lawyer Said Sandra Wanted WHAT Kind of Life?!
How does a defense lawyer explain a pregnancy announcement, a locked door, and a defendant who never takes the stand? That was the challenge at Matthew Farwell’s federal trial over Sandra Birchmore’s death. Jurors have now returned guilty verdicts on both counts, but the defense’s closing tells us a great deal about what they were asked to doubt. Tony Brueski is joined by Bob Motta of Defense Diaries and retired FBI behavioral expert Robin Dreeke. They combine two conversations: the defense’s No…
Lindsay Clancy: The Holdout Juror Ruling Changed WHAT?!
One juror can prevent a unanimous verdict. But can a judge remove that juror because everyone else reportedly disagrees? That question sits at the heart of Lindsay Clancy’s effort to stop a second murder trial after the September 4 mistrial. Tony Brueski and former prosecutor turned defense attorney Eric Faddis examine Clancy’s November 2 motion and Judge William Sullivan’s November 9 response. Her lawyers said eleven jurors were prepared to find her not criminally responsible in the deaths of C…





