
The Debate
A live debate on the topic of the day, with four guests. From Monday to Thursday at 7:10pm Paris time.
Latest Episodes
Three of a kind? Xi hosts Trump and Putin as Ukraine war grinds on
Gang of three or glorified photo op? Xi Jinping hosting Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin on the sidelines of the APEC summit. Already, our Monday panel rejected attempts to paint the three-way meeting as a new Yalta, as in the 1945 sit-down on the Black Sea that defined the post-war security architecture of Europe. We’ll ask if this was indeed little more than a PR exercise, what the leaders of China, Russia and the United States have in common. Could the trio even go full Yalta if they wanted to…
Xi welcomes Trump: Does Nvidia scandal upend US-China AI race?
You can strike Jensen Huang from the guest list, but good luck steering dinner conversation away from the topic in Shenzhen. The co-founder of the AI computing giant was set to accompany the US president to the APEC summit before he was undone by revelations of a dalliance with a Chinese national that happened to coincide with a Singapore client's backdoor skirting of sanctions on its powerful H200 chips. We ask about the fallout and the subsequent tightening of restrictions on US exports of chi…
The centre cannot hold? Splintered moderates lag in French presidential race
There's just five months to go before the French vote in the presidential election first round to choose Emmanuel Macron's successor. But it's not much of a race so far for the top two spots in the May 2 run-off: there's the far right's Marine Le Pen, the far left's Jean-Luc Mélenchon, with the other candidates lagging far behind. Whether it's on social media or in the streets, Le Pen and Mélenchon's supporters rule, in a radical break with the mainstream. A decade ago, it also felt like unchart…
Hard bargain: Should Ukraine trade Donbas for NATO membership?
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky is asserting that the United States has asked him about a straight-up swap: Russia gets the Donbas and the rest of Ukraine gets NATO membership – a guarantee against Moscow later having a second go and annexing the entire country. Whether or not the offer is real, serious or either side would accept it is another matter. We ask if the talk of partition signals some kind of turning point in a nearly five-year war that's at a brutal stalemate. The remarks cam…
Plugged-in planet? COP31 host Turkey leads charge for electrification
It's sweater weather in Paris. But even though November brings brisk temperatures and autumn foliage, it doesn't mean last summer's record heat should fade from our memories. One of the suggested reasons why students are so boiling mad is the hell they endured back in June in overheated classrooms and baking shoebox apartments. The global warming issue is compounded by the war in the Gulf driving up prices at the pump and in stores. In this, an El Niño year where the whole planet is prey to extr…
Undone by a honey trap? Nvidia's Jensen Huang at heart of China spy scandal
It turns out that the new masters of the universe are human – all too human. Nvidia co-founder Jensen Huang has admitted to an extramarital affair with Singapore-based Chinese tech CEO Alice Huang, who is no relation. She's under scrutiny over the purchase of Nvidia state-of-the-art chips that may have been smuggled back to the mainland illegally. China therefore stands accused of exploiting a vulnerability at the heart of the Silicon Valley giant that reigns supreme over two thirds of the plane…
Nvidia's Jensen Huang at heart of China spy scandal
Turns out that the new masters of the universe are human, all too human. China accused of exploiting a vulnerability at the heart of the Silicon Valley giant that reigns supreme over two-thirds of the planet’s AI computing power production, the Nvidia co-founder tempted by the flesh. Jensen Huang admitting to an extramarital affair with Singapore-based Chinese tech CEO Alice Huang - no relation. She’s under scrutiny over the purchase of Nvidia state-of-the-art chips that may have been smuggled b…
What the hack? Europeans face growing psyops and cyberattacks
So this time, it's Iran, not Russia? France – reportedly acting on US intelligence – is summoning Tehran's ambassador over last month's hacking of hundreds of supermarket refrigerators that overheated, 15 of which even caught fire. Why now, at a time when Iran is trying to break its international isolation? We ask about France's role in the region, particularly in defending Gulf states, and about all the other hacks and bomb threats that have rattled Europe in recent weeks, this as the continent…
Broken system? French protesters rage against austerity
How can the nation of haute couture and high-speed rail have an affordability issue? On paper, France boasts the planet's seventh-largest economy. Its top diplomat started the week hosting a G7 foreign ministers' meeting inside the regal setting of its landmark Left Bank ministry. But a few short blocks away, the prime minister was engaging in a more arduous exercise: negotiating pay rises with unions in a bid to quell social revolt while still keeping a record budget deficit from ballooning any…
Blue wave across America: Do US midterms signal beginning of the end for Trump?
He asked people to pretend he was on the ballot and they did. Voters across the United States have chased US President Donald Trump's Republican majorities from both houses of Congress. How big a landslide is this for the Democrats? We add up final ballot counts and ask if it's the beginning of the end for a US president who's broken norms in his second term with his outsized use of executive powers. How much of that power will he still wield in his final two years, particularly on the world sta…
Trickle or tsunami? Democrats eye gains in US midterm elections
Will it be a trickle, a wave, or a tsunami? It's Election Day in the United States, with Democrats hoping to take back one or both houses of Congress. We track the turnout, gauge the mood and raise the curtain ahead of midterm results that are sure to shape the last two years of Donald Trump's second and final term. Will a US president who’s already broken norms with his maximum use of executive powers be affected by the results a little, a lot, or not at all? In the run-up to FRANCE 24's electi…
Free and fair? The midterms and the state of US democracy
How far will the president of the United States press this time if Tuesday's midterm elections don't go his party's way? From "only if the Republicans win" campaign promises to a US Justice Department that's already got involved in races, will the White House weigh on the outcome? How will ballot counting go? What's changed since Donald Trump's "stop the steal" rhetoric led to the January 6, 2021 storming of the US Capitol? How much of a stress test are these US midterm elections for a US democr…
Michigan's El-Sayed targeted by Republicans in midterms race: Will the religion card work?
What in the name of political free speech is off limits? Can you say whatever you want on the campaign trail, no matter how false or racist it is? If you're the president of the United States, the answer is apparently yes. When Donald Trump calls Michigan Senate candidate Abdul El-Sayed a jihadist, it barely makes news. Does exposing voters to a daily diet of slander and slop work? Does it do lasting damage to our societies? We ask about El-Sayed vying to become the first ever Muslim elected to …
Which way will Israel break? Netanyahu still in it after election night surprises
In Israel, the surprises only start with election night. They're still counting ballots in a vote that featured the highest turnout in decades, historic inroads by Arab parties and Benjamin Netanyahu's worst result since 1999. And yet, Israel's longest-serving prime minister still has a path to staying in power. As we await the definitive makeup of the next parliament, our panel breaks out the calculators and pie charts: in what scenario does Netanyahu survive? Is the issue with the right-wing L…
Bibi's moment of truth: Israel votes in first general election since October 7 attacks
The turnout tells the tale. Israelis are casting ballots in their largest numbers in decades in the first general election since the October 7 attacks of 2023. The vote is seen as a referendum on the bloodiest day in the nation's history. But more broadly, what kind of Israel do citizens want? While traditional allies have long lost sympathy with the unending punishment inflicted on Gaza and the terror attacks by Jewish settlers in the West Bank, Israelis are instead divided over the new normal …
Comeback kid: How did Brazil's veteran leader Lula upset Bolsonaro?
Just two days shy of his 81st birthday, Brazil's Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva has emerged as the comeback kid. Coming from behind in the polls after a bitter campaign where he often showed his age, Lula has become the first candidate since Brazil’s return to democracy in the 1980s to win the presidential run-off after trailing in the first round. How did the Workers' Party leader turn a 2.2 million vote deficit against the far right's Flavio Bolsonaro into a 4.4 million vote win? Just three short w…
Back to the Bolsonaros? Brazil's presidential run-off goes down to the wire
Brazil's future is within the margin of error ahead of Sunday's presidential runoff: most of the latest polls put the far-right's Flavio Bolsonaro ahead of left-wing incumbent Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva – a lead that's narrowed after last weekend's acrimonious debate. We ask about crime, inequality and the other issues that could determine this nail-biter. We also ask whether the nearly 81-year-old Lula has lost his lustre of old, whether Brazilians are ready to overlook the attempted coup convic…
Europe's wave of anger: How far will youth-led protests go?
Youth-driven protests have been popping up all over Europe: in Belgium, Italy, Spain, Portugal, Albania, Serbia and Greece. The spark here in France was deteriorating conditions in high schools and universities, particularly for students from underprivileged backgrounds. Meanwhile, wages aren't keeping up with inflation. The housing crisis is front and centre in places like Spain and Portugal, while corruption and democratic backsliding have sparked uproar in Albania and Serbia. Last Saturday's …
AI on the ballot? Voters in US midterms revolt against data centres
Two weeks out from the US midterm elections, there's bipartisan pushback against data centres that suck the water and power out of communities. Just two years ago, ChatGPT was still a brand-new thing, and AI was admired with awe by most voters. Like in 2024, the hot-button issue in swing constituencies remains inflation, or "the price of eggs". But anxiety over the end of the month is now coupled with anxiety over the end of the world. In 2026, AI bots and large language models write papers and …
Out of control? France stunned by October 17 rioting
France didn't just erupt on Saturday – it exploded. Police were doubly overwhelmed by the turnout of the October 17 cost-of-living demonstrations, which saw two and-a-half times the crowds they expected. Officers were also overwhelmed by determined flashmobs: some radical militants hellbent on a fight, others who came for the looting. The whole world watched the assault on symbols of the Republic like the 19th-century city hall in Limoges, the usually quiet porcelain capital of France. There's a…



