The Dionysius Circle Podcast - Podcasts
Podcast

The Dionysius Circle Podcast

Samuel Walker Bennett
0 Plays

The Dionysius Circle Podcast focuses on Christian Platonism and the broader Platonic tradition. We study the integration of Platonism within Christian philosophy and theology, along with Plato himself and the later schools of Platonism. We also explore how Platonism developed in Jewish and Islamic thought. The project includes an ongoing interest in philosophical Platonism, both ancient and contemporary.For more, visit DionysiusCircle.org [http://dionysiuscircle.org/].

Latest Episodes

David A. Horner: Moral Arguments for God's Existence in Aristotle and Augustine

18 Nov 2026
1:28:27

Philosopher David A. Horner of Biola University joins me to discuss his new article on Aristotle, Augustine, and moral arguments for God's existence. Unlike theoretical moral arguments, which appeal to morality as evidence for God's existence, practical moral arguments ask whether our commitment to living morally gives us a reason to believe in God. Kant famously developed such an argument. Horner explores whether something similar can be found in Aristotle and Augustine, who understood morality…

Brendan Case: Bonaventure vs. Aquinas on Angels

12 Nov 2026
1:18:48

In Doubting Thomas: Early Franciscan Disputes with Aquinas, Brendan Case examines four disagreements between Aquinas and Bonaventure: whether knowing anything involves some awareness of God, what distinguishes the persons of the Trinity, whether reason can prove that the world had a beginning, and whether angels have matter. Brendan and I focus on the fourth. Both thinkers agree that angels have no bodies. Aquinas holds that angels are forms that exist without matter. Bonaventure grants that Aqu…

Brendan Case: Bonaventure vs. Aquinas on Angels

12 Nov 2026
1:19:34

Do angels have matter? Aquinas and Bonaventure agree that angels have no bodies, but they disagree about whether angels need matter to change. I discuss the disagreement with Brendan Case, author of Doubting Thomas: Early Franciscan Disputes with Aquinas. Aquinas holds that angels are forms that exist without matter. Also, he holds an angel’s essence is distinct from its existence. Bonaventure grants that the essence-existence distinction can explain why an angel depends on God for its existence…

Kevin Clarke on St. Maximus the Confessor: One Christ, Two Wills

19 Sep 2026
1:28:21

Kevin Clarke of Sacred Heart Seminary joins Sam Bennett and Dominic Cassella to discuss St. Maximus the Confessor’s Opuscula and Dispute with Pyrrhus. Clarke’s new translation and introduction is available here: https://www.amazon.com/Opuscula-Dispute-Pyrrhus-Theological-Polemical/dp/0813240824 We talk about why Maximus defended two wills and two activities in Christ, why his opponents thought this threatened Christ’s unity, and what was at stake for salvation. Other topics include Christ’s fear…

Max Rohstock on Dionysius and the Origin of Evil

07 Sep 2026
1:09:49

Max Rohstock argues that, for Dionysius, evil arises when human freedom turns away from the Good itself and becomes fixed on finite goods (wealth, power, pleasure) as though they were ultimate. Yet the Good never ceases to sustain us or call us back. In that sense, even our return to the Good begins from a grace that is already present.

Andreas Bergman: Why Baptism Is Necessary in St. Maximus the Confessor

03 Sep 2026
1:09:26

In this episode, we talk about a puzzle in St. Maximus the Confessor. First, Maximus holds that every human being already participates in Christ: Christ is the source, ordering principle, and final end of human nature. Second, Maximus says that the virtues are, in some sense, natural to us, and that the virtues lead to deification So why do we need baptism at all? Why does Maximus hold that baptism is necessary for deification and salvation if every human being already IN SOME SENSE participates…

Mark Blitz on Aristotle's Political Philosophy

09 Jul 2026
1:08:15

Political philosopher Mark Blitz joins the podcast to discuss his new book, Aristotle’s Political Philosophy. We consider Aristotle’s account of the link between political life and human happiness, the regime as a way of life, the place of virtue in liberal democracy, and the tensions between politics, philosophy, and religion. Patrick Jones joins me for the conversation.

The Function Argument in Aristotle's Ethics with Jakub Jirsa

09 Jul 2026
1:09:55

In this episode, Sam Bennett speaks with philosopher Jakub Jirsa about his new Bloomsbury book, The Function Argument in Aristotle’s Ethics. They discuss Aristotle’s famous function argument, what it means to ask whether human beings have a distinctive function, and how this question shapes Aristotle’s account of virtue, happiness, and the human good.

Aristotle's Argument Against Plato's Form of the Good - with Michele Pecorari

30 May 2026
1:28:10

In this episode, I speak with Michele Pecorari about one of Aristotle’s arguments against Plato’s Form of the Good in Nicomachean Ethics 1.6. Aristotle notes that we call many different kinds of things good: God is good, as a substance; virtue is good, as a quality; the right amount is good, as a quantity; and the right time is good, as a time. We discuss why Aristotle thinks this creates a problem for Plato’s idea of a single Form of the Good. The article discussed is Michele Pecorari’s “Goodne…

Gyula Klima on Ockham, Nominalism, and the Via Moderna

23 May 2026
1:27:04

Gyula Klima discusses the medieval problem of universals, focusing on the divide between the via antiqua and the via moderna. The conversation centers especially on William of Ockham’s break with the older realist tradition, drawing on Klima’s article “What is Wrong with Nominalism?” (Divinitas, 2, 2025). Klima argues that the deepest shift is not simply metaphysical, but semantic: a new account of how words, concepts, and things are related.

Karsten Harries on Nicholas of Cusa, Modernity, and Nihilism

12 May 2026
1:12:53

Karsten Harries, emeritus Yale professor of philosophy, joins Dr. Sam Bennett for a conversation on Nicholas of Cusa’s On Learned Ignorance, the limits of reason, modern science, nihilism, Kant, Heidegger, beauty, and transcendence in human life.

How Do We Know Essences? Aristotle's Answer with Christopher Hauser

17 Apr 2026
1:11:23

In this episode, philosopher Christopher Hauser of the University of Scranton joins Dr. Sam Bennett to discuss Aristotle’s epistemology, specifically his theory of essence and how we come to know essences. We begin by clarifying what Aristotle means by essence, including the distinction between individuals and kinds, and between essential features and merely necessary properties. The conversation then turns to a central question in Aristotle’s philosophy: how do we grasp the fundamental definiti…

Piero Boitani on the Timaeus, Beauty, and Poetic Thought

24 Mar 2026
1:14:34

In this episode, Dr Sam Bennett speaks with the Italian literary critic and poet Piero Boitani about his recent book Timaeus in Paradise: Metaphors and Beauty from Plato to Dante and Beyond, alongside his long poetic work Plato’s Poem. We begin with the remarkable story behind these works, including the unexpected emergence of poetic inspiration late in Piero's life. From there, the conversation turns to the enduring influence of Plato’s Timaeus, especially its reception in the Western tradition…

Plato vs. Aristotle: A Fundamental Divide? With Dr. Rares Marinescu

28 Feb 2026
1:10:06

In this episode, Sam Bennett speaks with Dr. Rareș Ilie Marinescu about the depth of the disagreement between Plato and Aristotle. Rareș is a Postdoctoral Fellow in Classics at the University of Toronto and the author of Proclus on Aristotle on Plato: A Case Study on Motion. Do Plato and Aristotle merely disagree at the surface level, or do they diverge at the level of first principles? Is motion ultimately explained by a self moving soul or by an unmoved intellect? Can a self moving soul truly …

Against Aristotelian Universals: Two Arguments from Damiano Costa

14 Jan 2026
1:07:28

This episode is a discussion with philosopher Damiano Costa about his paper “An Argument Against Aristotelian Universals.” Costa examines the Aristotelian view that universals really exist, yet depend for their existence on being exemplified by particular things, and he explains why he thinks this position cannot be sustained. The discussion focuses on two arguments against Aristotelian universals. The first targets the idea that the existence of a universal is grounded in exemplification. Costa…

The Problem of Universals: A Conversation with Gyula Klima

11 Dec 2025
1:03:17

In this episode, Sam Bennett speaks with Gyula Klima about the medieval problem of universals and the philosophical issues that arise when we try to explain how universal cognition of singular things is possible. Klima begins with his intellectual background and then walks through the problem as it develops from Plato’s ideal objects and the challenge posed by the Third Man argument, to Aristotle’s account of abstraction and universal concepts. He discusses Augustine’s placement of universals in…

The Nature of Evil: Privation or Corruption? with Christophe de Ray

06 Nov 2025
1:09:50

In this episode, I talk with Dr. Christophe de Ray from Nanyang Technological University about his article “Corruptio Boni: An Alternative to the Privation Theory of Evil,” published in the journal Ratio: An International Journal of Analytic Philosophy. Drawing inspiration from Augustine, Dr. de Ray argues that evil is not the mere absence of a good that ought to obtain, but rather the corruption of a good: something that harms, diminishes, or destroys it.

Evil as Privation: A Conversation with Pierce Alexander Marks

09 Oct 2025
1:23:52

What kind of thing is evil? If all being is good, where does disorder come from? Can evil have reality without being a substance? In this episode, we talk with philosopher Pierce Marks about his paper “Evil as Privation: Its True Meaning and Import.” We discuss the Platonic roots of the view that evil is a lack of the good, the distinction between “mere” and “depraved” privations, and whether natural evils like death or predation are genuine evils or part of the world’s perfection.

Justification Revisited: Maximus the Confessor and the New Perspective on Paul

07 Aug 2025
1:10:59

In this episode, Dr. Andreas Bergman joins us to discuss his recent open-access article, The Maximian Perspective on Paul: A Reconstruction of the Works of the Law and Maximus the Confessor. We begin by outlining the main features of the Old and New Perspectives on Paul, particularly the contested meaning of the phrase “works of the law” in Pauline theology. From there, we explore how Maximus the Confessor’s ascetical theology complicates and enriches this debate. Dr. Bergman explains Maximus’s …

Participation and Righteousness in Paul and Gregory of Nyssa – A Conversation with Dr. Joshua Heavin

12 Jun 2025
1:14:00

In this episode of the Dionysius Circle podcast, I explore with New Testament scholar Dr. Joshua Heavin his recent article on participation in Christ and divine and human righteousness. Drawing from both Paul’s letters and the theology of St. Gregory of Nyssa, we examine how righteousness is not merely a moral property but, at its deepest level, a person — Christ himself. We also unpack Gregory’s fourfold model of participation and how it offers a transformative vision of the Christian life.

Podcasts

Comments & Reviews0